What Happened In March 1862
The War in the West
u00a0Henry Halleck Plans a Campaign
Henry W. Halleck came to the Civil War, a West Point graduate, a published
author of highly acclaimed military studies, a successful army officer, lawyer
and businessman who gained high reputation and considerable wealth for himself
in California. But he is generally dismissed by the historians and civil war
writers as a pompous, slow-witted army administrator who contributed nothing
substantial to the progress of Union arms. In fact, Halleck contributed a great
deal to the success of Union arms, at least up to the point he replaced
McClellan as Lincoln's "general-in-chief," in July 1862. And the
fault for his failure as general-in-chief must lie more with Lincoln than
On November 19, 1861, Henry Halleck was assigned command of
the Department of Missouri, which now included the territory of Arkansas as well as that part of Kentucky that lies between the Mississippi and Tennessee rivers.
Situation When Halleck Arrived at St. Louis
Halleck had been preceded in command of the Department by three
Union commandersu0097William S. Harney, Nathaniel Lyons, and John C. Fremont; a
fourth commanderu0097David Hunteru0097held the position for two weeks, pending the
arrival of Halleck after Lincoln fired Fremont. Halleck's assignment was to
bring Missouri finally and firmly into the Union camp, and then to organize a
movement to open the Mississippi as far southward as Memphis.
At the outbreak of the war, in April 1861, the government of
Missouri, located at Jefferson City in the center of the State, had collapsed,
with the governor, Claiborne Jackson, most of the Legislature, and the State's
Militia, under General Sterling Price, taking up the Confederate cause. (Most
of Missouri, outside the limits of Saint Louis, was Confederate in sympathy but
sparsely populated.) This event led the section of the State north of the Missouri River into a classic condition of guerilla warfare, with Confederate sympathizers
roaming the countryside killing Union sympathizers, looting Union households,
and destroying railroad bridges. Sterling Price, in conjunction with Ben
McCulloch, who arrived with reinforcements from Arkansas, roamed the southwestern
sector of the state between Lexington and Springfield; and Confederate forces
from Tennessee appeared in the later stages of this period at New Madrid, in
the southeastern corner of the State, and roamed between that point and
Railroad Net In Missouri
Shortly after Lincoln's first call for volunteers, in April
1861, Francis Blair, Jr., a member of Congress and the leader of the Union
party in St. Louis, in cooperation with Nathaniel Lyon, organized an armed body
of men who took control of the arsenal in the city and drove the Confederates beyond
the city limits to the west. For the period immediately following
thisu0097essentially the three month volunteers' period of enlistmentu0097William S.
Harney, a career Army officer of Southern background, acted as department
commander. Harney was inclined to maintain the peace by negotiation with
Missouri Governor Jackson and Sterling Price and this caused him to fall into
violent political clashing with Blair. This in turn threw Missouri's political
and military affairs into such wild confusion, that Lincolnu0097with the Blair
family's proddingu0097replaced Harney with John C. Fremont.
In the interval between Harney's dismissal and Fremont's arrival in St. Louis, Nathaniel Lyon, taking command of the Union force of Missouri volunteers, and using the railroad head at Rolla as his base, proceeded to move
toward Springfield to engage Price and McCullough. Accompanying Lyon, in command of a column, was Franz Sigel, a German immigrant who was very important to
Lincoln's effort to enlist troops from the German population of St. Louis, but a combat officer who would prove himself deficient in several respects. This
movement eventually turned out badly, when Lyon was killed in battle at Springfield just as Fremont was establishing his department headquarters at St. Louis.
Fremont was a career army officer who had gained a national reputation publishing a book
about his explorations through the Rocky Mountains to the Pacific Coast. This, along with his public expression of views regarding slavery, led, in turn, to his
nomination as presidential candidate of the Republican Party, in 1856. (By
1856, Fremont had resigned from the army and was operating a mining venture in
California.) Appointed by Lincoln as one of four major-generals in the Regular
Army while he was in Europe on business, Fremont returned to the United States in June 1861, visited with Lincoln at the White House, spent some time in New York, and then took train to St. Louis, arriving there on July 25, several days after
Lyon was killed at Springfield.
Dates of Appt.
and Rank, Regular Army Major-Generals, 1861
Relative to General Officers, War Dept. 1906)
*graduate of West Point
Dates of Appt.
and Rank, Regular Army Brigadier-Generals, 1861
Thirty-five days after his arrival, on August 30, Fremont issued his famous proclamation, declaring that he was taking the State
Government's administrative powers to himself, placing the State under martial
law, and announcing that the slaves of all persons proven to be rebels in
military trials would be freemen. Fremont's declaration was the first public
admission that as far as the Republican Party was concerned the object of the
war was to free the slaves by force. Fremont proclaimed:
Fremont published his proclamation, knowing that its terms
exceeded in scope the authority for confiscation that the Congress of the United States had established as law, twenty days before.
Act of August 6, 1861
"Sec 4: Whenever hereafter, during
the present insurrection against the Government of the United States, any
person claimed to be held to labor under the law of any state, shall be
required to take up arms against the United States or to be employed upon any
fortification, the right of the person owning him shall be forfeit, and
whenever the owner shall seek to enforce his claim to such labor, it shall be a
full defense against the claim that the person bound to labor was forced to
labor against the United States."
The only practical difference between Fremont's proclamation
and the law of Congress was that, under Fremont's scheme, the factual basis for
confiscation was to be proven in a military tribunal under the law of war (the
method the 2000-2011 Congress has adopted for its "war on
terror"), while, under the 1861 Congress's scheme, the factual
basis was to be established in a federal court. Notwithstanding that this
important difference did not change the issue to be decidedu0097was
the defendant guilty of the offense chargedu0097the public's perception of
what was the object of the war immediately changed, and a wave of
political hysteria engulfed the people of the border States, especially in Kentucky.
Kentucky, at this time, was tenuously holding to the
position that it was a neutral entity, not engaged in the military struggle
between the States. Although its governor, Beriah Magoffin, was pro-Confederate
in sympathy, the State Government continued to function and a developing
majority of its members was slowly swinging its support toward the Union. By the time Fremont issued his proclamation, Lincoln was actively encouraging the
Union elements in the State, by shipping rifles into the state and supporting
the set up of recruitment camps. By late August, the secessionist movement no
longer seemed to have any prospect of success, and the State's politics were trending
toward abandoning neutrality in favor of actively engaging in the war on the
side of the Union.
Fremont's proclamation caused the pro-Union movement to hesitate
and this seriously threatened a reverse in Kentucky's course. Joshua Speed, a
Kentuckian and one of Lincoln's oldest friends, wrote him to say at this time,
"I have been so distressed since reading that foolish proclamation of Fremont that I have been unable to sleep or eat. To wage war in a slave state on such a
principle as the proclamation expresses" is stupid; "you might as
well attack the freedom of worship or the right of a parent to teach his child
to read." Speed's letter was followed by a shower of telegrams reaching Lincoln's desk from various parts of the State, with the unanimous cryu0097"There is not
a day to lose in disavowing emancipation or Kentucky is gone over the mill
dam." Lincoln reacted to this, on September 4u0097the day the Confederates,
under Gideon Pillow, occupied Columbus, Kentucky, in forceu0097by asking Fremont to
modify his proclamation, to conform its terms to those of the congressional act
of confiscation. Lincoln wrote Fremont, on September 2, 1861, "I think there is great danger, in relation to the liberating of slaves of
traitorous owners, that our southern Union friends will be alarmed and turn
against us; perhaps ruin our rather fair prospect for Kentucky." (How Fremont's proclamation accentuated this "alarm" more so than did the
Congressional confiscation law, Lincoln did not explain.)
Fremont, not quite as unreasonably as the historians tend to
say, flatly refused. He was the military commander of the
department, after all, and the department was seriously being
disrupted by an extremely hostile population in the countryside, especially in
the section of the State north of the Missouri River, that was tearing up the
railroad tracks faster than they could be repaired, burning railroad bridges,
and relentlessly murdering Lincoln's dear Union friends. Indeed, Fremont had
been the first standard bearer of the Republican Party, had run on the platform
of freedom for the slaves, (something Lincoln had not done.), and he was clearly
in full agreement with the Radicals of the party who were then beginning to
stand in the Senate and House of Representatives to make fiery speeches
designed to force that very issue home to a conclusion.
Fremont politely replied to Lincoln, on September 8th,
writing: "I did it, acting solely with my best judgment to serve the
country and yourself. This is as much a movement in the war as a battle, and in going into these I shall have to act according to my judgment, as I
did on this occasion. If you still decide I am wrong I have to ask that you
openly direct me to make the correction. If I were to retract it would imply I
myself thought it wrong, but I thought it was a measure right and necessary and
I think so still." Lincoln accommodated him quickly.
By September, Fremont was spending hundreds of thousands of
dollars turning St. Louis into a fortified city on the scale that Washington was, while the entire state continued to be embroiled in guerilla warfare; worse,
the Union columns in the field were suffering reversals. Lyons had been killed
at Springfield, his associate, Franz Sigel, thereafter had made a hasty retreat
toward Rolla, and Price had moved north and captured a 2,400 man Union garrison
at Lexington and was now dallying between the two points. At the same time,
Confederate forces were appearing at New Madrid and Columbus, Kentucky, with
elements trending northward toward the Iron Mountain Railroad connecting St. Louis to Ironton.
Fremont reacted to these events, by making some important
decisions which would prove to have a dramatic effect on the progress of the
war: he made a perhaps not so surprising change in district commanders; he
supported a movement that resulted in the seizure of Paducah and Smithland at
the mouths of the Tennessee and Cumberland rivers; he ordered a concentration
of forces at Jefferson City, for a movement westward against Price and
McCulloch; and he intensified efforts to suppress the civilian marauding that
was going on in the counties north of the Missouri.
He was doing these things under circumstances in which the
Lincoln Government had not yet fully supported him with money and supplies: his
troops were operating at this time woefully short of shoes, clothing, food,
ammunition, efficient rifles, wagons, horses, and artillery.(Of course, the
Confederate commanders were in the same boat.) While his aggressive efforts
were in progress, not only did Montgomery Blair, Postmaster General, and Montgomery
Meigs, the Army's Quartermaster General, appear at St. Louis to
"investigate" the situation; but also Simon Cameron, Secretary of
War, and Lorenzo Thomas, Adjutant General of the Army, showed up. Cameron had
in hand a letter authorizing Fremont's removal from command, which he showed Fremont but did not officially serve, because Fremont, then at Jefferson City, convinced
him that he was entitled to a chance to prove himself in the field.
What objectively justified Lincoln's decision to discharge Fremont at this point is difficult to fathom, unless you are an academic historian
repeating the myth of history. Fremont had arrested, released, and rearrested
Frank Blair, Jr. for "insubordination" during this time. Blair and
Fremont had been at loggerheads, because Fremont would not give Blair's cronies
the contracts they coveted. Fremont was indeed prancing about, somewhat
ostentatiously, with a crowd of over-dressed foreigners around him, and, no
doubt, his cronies were making huge war profit from their
relationship with him. But this was standard operating procedure for many
politicians and military officers in position to take personal advantages. (As
to the latter point Cameron, himself, was well known to be doing exactly the
Perhaps, to escape the necessity of interviews, the embarrassing
politics, or to rehabilitate his shrinking standing with Lincoln, Fremont left St. Louis and went to the front, personally leading an army of three newly
organized divisions, under the command of Franz Sigel, John Pope, and David
Hunter, out into the field to do battle with Price and McCulloch. Eventually,
in late October, Fremont's army converged on Springfield which Price had
abandoned a week before. By November 2, all of the divisions were in line of
battle, Fremont apparently expecting to be attacked at any moment; then,
suddenly, David Hunter appeared with Lincoln's order relieving Fremont of command in hand and delivered it.
Whether Fremont's dismissal was based on the actual record
of his military performance as department commander, or was the consequence of his
taking to himself all political power within the department or because of
financial mismanagement remains a question unanswered persuasively by the
historians. Clearly, Lincoln's organizing a formidable party to confront Fremont in St. Louis suggests Lincoln saw Fremont as a political power to be reckoned
with. Lincoln's real concern with Fremont may well have been the fact that, by
his political actions,u00a0 Fremont was positioning himself to be the leader of the
Radical faction of the Republican Party, and, therefore, becoming an obstacle
to Lincoln's ability to control the party's war agenda, and therefore had to be
Bodyguard Charges Through Springfield
Seven days after dismissing Fremont, Lincoln named
Major-General Henry W. Halleck commander of the Department of Missouri. Within
three months of that date, Halleck's administration of the department,
acknowledged by all to have been in chaos when he took it overu0097with most of its
u00a0troops unpaid, many without clothing and arms, large numbers absent from duty,
and the rebels holding sway almost everywhereu0097had resulted in Missouri and
Kentucky being completely cleared of enemy troops, and his several army corps,
under the field command of Curtis, Pope, Grant and Buell, were penetrating deep
into Arkansas and Tennessee, gathering themselves by the end of March to move
on the strategic point of Corinth, Mississippiu0097the crossroads of the Mobile
& Ohio Railroad and the Memphis & Charleston Railroad. Then, Halleck
thought, it would be "on to Memphis!"
Henry Halleck's record, during this period, is a string of military
victories. Concentrating, first, on clearing Missouri, Halleck managed the
operations of three armies, one operating in eastern Missouri with the
objective of clearing the Mississippi down to the Arkansas border, another
operating in the southwestern corner of the state, with the objective of
pursuing the enemy into Arkansas, and the last operating up the Tennessee River. As the first two objectives were achieved, Halleck niftily shifted his
resources from Missouri to Kentucky, ordering Grant, who had emerged from the
pack of regimental officers as a brigadier-general in command at Cairo, Illinois, to capture Fort Henry and thereby threaten Sidney Johnston's rear at Bowling Green. This movement, in conjunction with Buell's crossing his army over the Barren River, caused Johnston, who could not stand a battle against Buell's superior force,
to abandon Nashville and retreat into Alabama.
As a consequence of Halleck's success, Lincoln caused the
Department of Missouriu0097renamed the "Department of the Mississippi"u0097to
be extended to include the territory between the Tennessee River and the Barren
River down to the Alabama and Mississippi borders which brought Buell's army
under Halleck's command, and, suddenly, Ulysses Grant was a major-general of
volunteers outranking everyone except Halleck, Pope, and Ethan Hitchcock,
grandson of Revolutionary War hero Ethan Allan and a Lincoln military advisor.
Hitchcock was brevetted a brigadier-general for his conduct
at the battle of Molino del Rey during the war with Mexico, became colonel of
the 2nd U.S. Infantry Regiment, in 1851, commander of the Department of the
Pacific, in 1864, and, when made a major-general, became a special advisor to
Edwin Stanton, Secretary of War on February 17, 1862, a position that lasted
until November 1862. As such, Hitchcock acted as President of the "War
Board" which was composed of a group of staff officers who provided
counsel and advise to Lincoln. Lincoln had plenty of "advisors."
John Pope's Star Rises
On February 17, Halleck had ordered Grant to stop where he
was, at Fort Donelson, and directed that all reinforcements previously ordered
to move up the Tennessee and Cumberland rivers were to retrace their route and
go to Pope's headquarters which was now in southeastern Missouri. On February
18th, Halleck ordered Pope to organize these troops into the "Army of
Mississippi" and use them to capture New Madrid and Island No. Ten.
Halleck's idea, here, much like Fremont's before him, was to get in the rear of
the Confederate stronghold at Columbus, cut off its communications with the
South and thereby clear the Mississippi River down to Memphis. Once Columbus was abandoned by the rebels, Halleck could use the Mobile & Ohio Railroad to
support his armies' movement on Corinth, Mississippi. Grant, though, had a
different idea which Halleck eventually came around to. But, first, the
paramount objective was to clear the Mississippi River as far downstream from Cairo as possible and in this endeavor, Halleck first thought John Pope was the man.
the war commenced, in April 1861, John Pope was a first lieutenant in the U.S.
Army; trained as a topographical engineer, he was then stationed at Cincinnati with the assignment of planning lighthouses for the Great Lakes. Previous to
this, he had spent seventeen years mapping and exploring trails across the Great Plains. A family friend of Lincoln, Pope had accompanied the president-elect on the
train ride that carried him to his inauguration at Washington, in March 1861.
Within a day of Sumter's fall, Pope wrote a telegram to Illinois Governor
Richard Yates, offering his services. Yates responded, with an offer to make
Pope the State's "mustering officer." Pope immediately accepted
Yates's offer and, after obtaining, through Lincoln's intervention, a leave of
absence from the Regular Army, he went directly to Springfield. Pope performed
the duties of State Mustering Officer for about a month; by May 5, he had
mustered into the Illinois State Militia six volunteer Militia regiments whose
members had volunteered to serve for ninety days.
During this time, Pope tried to gain the position of Militia
General for Illinois, but Governor Yates allowed the men in the ranks of the
six regiments to vote for the man they wanted to fill this position and they
chose Benjamin Prentiss. Prentiss, an active Republican, had led a company of Illinois volunteers in the war with Mexico, seeing action at a number of battles. After the
war he remained active in the Illinois Militia, rising to the rank of colonel. Losing
out to Prentiss, Pope then turned to his social and political connectionsu0097he
had married into a wealthy Republican Ohio family and he was on first name
terms with the key Republicans in both Ohio and Illinoisu0097to press Lincoln for appointment as a brigadier-general in the Regular Army. Instead, Lincoln appointed him, along with another Illinoisan, Stephen Hurlbut, a brigadier-general
When Congress convened its special session on July 4th, Lincoln's nominations, including that of George McClellan, then Ohio Militia General, to
major-general of the Regular Army, were confirmed by the Senate and McClellan
ordered Pope to take command of six Illinois volunteer regiments stationed at Alton, Illinois. Soon after Pope arrived at Alton, Nathaniel Lyon, commanding the Missouri
Volunteer forces, asked Governor Yates to provide Illinois troops to guard the
Hannibal & St. Joseph Railroad. This railroad provided western Illinois with the means of communicating with Kansas and the West, and Governor Yates,
wanting to keep it open to Illinois commerce, ordered Pope to move into Northern Missouri and cooperate with Lyons. (During the period of ninety day enlistments,
specified by Lincoln in his first call for volunteers, the state governors
commanded their state militias and assigned the general officer slots; this
practice was cut out when the three year enlistments began replacing the ninety
Two weeks later, John Fremont took command of the western department
and placed Pope in command of the District of North Missouri, with instructions
to suppress marauding and cover the railroads. Pope was energetic in executing
Fremont's instructions: spreading his regiments through the district, posting
forces at the county seats of each county, he forced the citizens in each
county to form "safety committees" the function of which was to preserve
order. Pope was the first in this regard to impose military force on a civilian
population in the Civil War.
to the People of Marion County
HEADQUARTERS DISTRICT OF NORTH MISSOURI
u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0 St. Charles, July 21, 1861
I desire the people of this section of
the State to understand distinctly that their safety and the security of their
property will depend upon themselves, and are directly and inseparably
connected with the security of the lines of public communication.
It is very certain that the people
living along the line of the North Missouri Railroad can very easily protect it
from destruction, and it is my purpose to give them very strong inducements to
do so. I therefore notify the inhabitants of the towns, villages, and stations
along the line of this road that they will be held accountable for the destruction
of any bridges, culverts, or portions of the railroad track within five miles
on each side of them. If any outrages of this kind are committed within the
distance specified, without conclusive proof of active resistance on the part
of the population, and without immediate information to the nearest commanding
officer, giving names and details, the settlement will be held responsible, and
a levy of money or property sufficient to cover the whole damage done will be
at once made and collected. If people who claim to be good citizens choose to
indulge their neighbors in committing these wanton acts, and to shield them
from punishment, they will hereafter be compelled to pay for it.
To carry out the intentions set forth
above, divisions of the road will be made from these headquarters, and
superintendents appointed by name, without regard to political opinions, who
will be held responsible for the safety of the railroad track within their
specified limits. They will have authority to call on all persons living within
these limits to appear in such numbers and at such times and places as they
deem necessary to secure the object in view.
U.S. Army, Commanding North Missouri
With this "notice" Brigadier-General Pope, of the
U.S. Army Volunteers, joined a long list of soldiers who have ignored the laws
of war, punishing the civilian population of a militarily occupied territory
with the summary use of military force, as the Germans did to the French in
World War II, the American army did to village people in Viet Nam, and, it is
hard to ignore, also in Iraq and Afghanistan. As Pope explained, when called to
account for this conduct, it is the way of the military in the circumstanceu0097they
call it today, "counterinsurgency measures." Responding to inquiries
from important Missourians, Pope wrote this:
"When I arrived in North Missouri to assume command I found the whole country in commotion, bridges and
railroad tracks destroyed, and the entire population in a state of excitement.
My first object was to restore quiet and secure the property from marauders.
As soon as these marauders found that
troops were approaching, which they easily did, from the very persons who ask
for protection, they dispersed to their homes, sure that their neighbors would
shield them from exposure.
Two courses were open to me to stop
this: the first was to use small bodies of troops to hunt down the parties in
arms. This course would have led to frequent and bloody encounters, to
searching of homes, and arrests in many cases of innocent persons, and would
only have resulted in spreading the apprehension of distress over districts
hitherto quiet. To spare the effusion of blood, destruction of life or
property, and harassing and ofttimes undiscriminating outrage upon the people,
I have determined to present the people, some common inducement to preserve the
peace in their own midst. The common bond is their private property,
always in my power, though the owner might be beyond my reach. I have
not the slightest inclination to play the tyrant to any man on earth. If the
people keep the peace they will neither see me nor my command."
The complaints Pope had received from influential
Missourians eventually reached John Fremont's desk and he called Pope to St. Louis, in late August, for consultation about them. Upon leaving the conference, Pope
wrote Fremont this epistle:
"This system of holding property
of counties responsible for breaches of the peace enlists the active agency of
the secessionists in keeping down riots and disturbances. When so large a
portion of the population sympathizes with the authors of the atrocious acts of
guerilla warfare, it is impossible to apprehend the perpetrators of such
outrages. Since the population has been notified that their property would be
made to pay the expense of suppressing such disturbances, thousand of persons
have taken part in preventing them. Marion County, from which came the protests
against this policy, has been the worst county in the State. Whenever it is discovered
that the policy will not be executed, I firmly believe that every county will
be in a state of tumult, and will require for the restoration of peace five
times the force now needed.. Therefore I recommend you make no favorable reply
to those complaining of this policy. True, there is a risk of alienating a few
men hitherto half-way for the Union; but there is great risk, if it is not
enforced, of having every county in arms against the peace."
The Counties of
in 1862, was the site of a massacre
caused by Union
It appears from the record that the Missourians' complaints
to Fremont passed without a change of military policy, as Afghanistan President Karzi's complaints of constant home invasions in the night have gone
ignored today: so much for Bush's guru general, now Obama's CIA Director,
Petreaus's "original" book on "counterinsurgency" tactics.
Then, with Fremont removed and Halleck in his place, Pope
found himself, on March 3 1862, with an army of 10,000 in front of New Madrid;
and the next day he ordered an attack. The attack failed when Confederate
gunboats, unopposed by Union gunboats, which at the moment were unable to get
past shore batteries on the northern reaches of the river, covered the
Confederate infantry with the fire of their guns.
Pope brought down from Cairo more artillery and, by March
12th, he was pounding the Confederate position at New Madrid and suppressing
the fire from the Confederate gunboats. This induced the Confederate commander
to abandon New Madrid the night of March 14th, taking his men by ferry across
the river and into the peninsula formed by the bend you see in the image.
this point, Halleck sent Foote's flotilla of gunboats, which after Donelson, had
refitted at Cairo, down the Mississippi to support Pope's effort. The gunboats
arrived on March 16th and tied to the shore at a point just north of Island No.
Ten. On March 17th, Foote's gunboats and mortar boats barraged the Confederate fortifications
but accomplished nothing. The Confederates had forty-nine guns in operation and
the artillery exchange resulted in serious damage to several of Foote's boats.
Afraid his boats would float downstream into rebel hands if they became
disabled, Foote backed off.
Now came the first canal-digging venture of the war. In
order to capture the rebel position, Pope had to get his infantry across the
river and into the mouth of the peninsula. To do this, he decided to dig a
canal through the swampland that bordered the river on the west bank and in
that way get transport boats to New Madrid which he could then use to move his
army from the west to the east bank and attack the rebel fortifications from
the rear. Three weeks were spend in this endeavor: Eight hundred black laborers,
by removing snags and dead trees from the mud bottom, threaded a shallow channel
through the swamp over a 15 mile course. Presumably they were paid.
Then, on March 30, with this work completed, Flag Officer
Foote found a volunteer, Captain Walke, of the Carondelet,
willing to attempt to run past the rebel batteries; the idea being to get some
gunnery support to Pope as he attempted to cross his troops over the river in
the transports. The stage was now set for Pope to emerge as a principal player
in the opening of the Mississippi River down to Memphis and win from Lincoln the coveted commission as a Regular Army brigadier.
u00a0Grant's Star Almost Crashes
The record seems to show that Ulysses Grant was, in fact, a
strange, sullen sort of man. Raised in rural southern Ohio, he spent his youth
working for years against his will in his father's tannery, scraping blood and
bits of bone and muscle off the bloody hides of dead animals. As a young boy he
was worked hard; when not scraping cowhides, he was working on the family farm,
doing "all the work done with horses" the experience making him a
master horseman. His father, Jesse, was successful at the tannery business and
had money in the bank which he used eventually to bankroll a leather goods
business, to be run by Ulysses's two younger brothers, Simpson and Orvil, in Galena, Illinois. For whatever reason, however, instead of grooming Ulysses to work in
business with his other sons, Jesse pushed him into West Point. The father must
have seen something in the son that he thought was special; watching how his
son got hard things done, it might well have been the trait of u00a0initiative he saw and it made him think of West Point. Or, perhaps, it was just that he realized
Ulysses was smart and a college education could be gained for him that cost his
Initiative: 1. the action
of taking the first step; responsibility for beginning; 2. ability to think and
act without being urged.
Grant entered West Point in 1839 at the age of seventeen.
His classmates included George McClellan, William Sherman, James Longstreet and
Stonewall Jackson. Upon graduation, in 1843, as a second lieutenant of
infantry, Grant, with his West Point roommate, Charles Dent, was stationed at
Jefferson Barracks, St. Louis, and there he met and married Julia Dent, Charles's
sister. Two years later he was at the Rio Grande River, with Zachary Taylor's
small army, and, engaging as an infantry company commander in the actions at
Palo Alto and Resaca de la Palma, he witnessed at close hand men being maimed
and killed around him as he charged the Mexican cannon with the rest of
Taylor's little army. At this early moment, it seems Grant learned something
about the horror of war; writing Julia, he said: "The woods was strewn
with the dead. Wagons, how many I cannot guess, drew the bodies to
burial." As to the stress of battle felt to himself, he wrote her:
"There is no great sport in having bullets flying about one in every
direction, but I find they have less horror when you are among them."
After these actions, Taylor invaded Mexico, marching his column of 3,000 men to Monterrey; there, Grant rode a horse, until it
was shot from under him, in the charges on the city's fort as about a third of
the men involved fell killed or wounded. Once past the fort, Grant ran with the
infantry attack force through the town, darting from house to house, down one
street, then another, until, just as Worth's army was arriving from the
opposite direction, the recall was sounded and the battle died out, allowingu00a0
the Mexican troops to leave the place with their arms intact. Then, in 1847,
Grant, now a quartermaster, was sent, with his regiment, to join General Scott
who had arrived at Vera Cruz with 10,000 men. As a consequence, Grant saw action
at the Pass of Cerro Gordo, on the climb out from the sea; at Puebla, where
Scott built up a depot of supply, and then at the approaches to Mexico
Cityu0097Molino del Rey and Chapultepecu0097and finally at the city itself,u00a0 he led a
squad of men, dragging a howitzer into a church belfry and dispersed the
Mexicans defending the city's San Cosme Gate.
The Assault on
the City of Mexico, September 1847
Break Through at the San Cosme Gate
Four years later, married now to Julia Dent, Grant and his
4th Infantry company, arrived at Fort Columbus, Oregon, alone. His wife was
pregnant with their first child and could not come; and after delivering the
child she did not come. After a leave of absence that got his wife pregnant a
second time, he was transferred to Fort Humbolt, at Eureka, California. There,
isolated and alone in a place almost constantly shrouded in the cold gloom of
the North Coast, without the companionship of a wife and never having seen his children,
it is said, with some authority, that Grant began to drink.
As the spring of 1854 was beginning, with no sunshine, Grant
received notice of promotion to captain and, after accepting, at once resigned
his commission. In the last letter he wrote Julia from Humboldt, his words seem
to make plain that his unhappiness may have been occasioned in large measure by
his wife's voluntary absence. "Dear Wife," he wrote her on May 2, 1854, "I have not received a letter from you and as I will be away from here
in a few days do not expect to. You might write directing it to New York City." Five months later, he was reunited with her at her family's home at St. Louis and within a week she was pregnant with their third child.
The Dent Family
Julia's father, a slaveholder and large scale farmer, gave
Grant some acreage to begin a farm. Grant cleared the land of trees, using the
lumber to build a two-story house.
Julia was not happy: "Is this my destiny?" she
wrote years later about the experience. Julia, in her father's "nice frame
house," had had financial advantages and enjoyed material advantages that
life on the "farm" apparently denied her. There, it became evident
there was little money available for anything other than the necessities of
life and this bothered her. Farmers were generally suffering at this time and
Grant shared in it; for two years, the income from his crops and cordwood sales,
the historians say, barely covered household expenses and the cost of hiring
slave labor. (Yet, Julia owned four slaves, one of which, a maid, she took with
her, during the war, when she visited her husband in camp. In 1859, Grant
manumitted the one slave that he owned.) Whether, by the spring of 1860 Grant
was as poor as the historians say, he joined the family leather business in
Galena, Illinois, and put his wife and children in a rented frame house (A more
objective reason for doing this is that his brother Simpson was terminally ill
and was no longer available to help in the family's Galena business.)
Family's Home in Galena, Illinois
year later, Grant accompanied a company of Galena volunteers to the Illinois
State Capitol at Springfield and, within a few days, found himself appointed by
Governor Yates to the position of the State's Mustering Officer. As the
historians tell it, Grant arrived at Springfield, a confirmed failure in life,
a man of no reputation and no promise, seedy in appearance, with a near
hobo-like demeanor. Nothing could be farther from the objective truth.
Grant and the Galena volunteers arrived at Springfield on April 25, 1861, and he went with them to Camp Yates, the State's mustering grounds. Here
he came in contact with John Pope, who then held the position of State Mustering
Officer. The two men had been classmates at West Pointu0097Pope being a year ahead of
Grantu0097and they both had been with Zachary Taylor's army as it came upon
Monterrey and had run together under fire through the city streets. Pope, as a
topographical engineer, was with Captain Joseph Mansfield, at one point crouched
against a wall as canister fire from the Mexican artillery raked the streets;
and Grant, not far away, had a horse shot from under him as he tried to bring
ammunition to his comrades while Taylor's wing of the attack was giving way. At
the end of the day, as the fire was dying away, and a sort of truce prevailed, they
had both walked among the dead bodies of the soldiers lying in the streets,
looking this way and that, for wounded; both drenched in dripping sweat by the
experience of war.
Meeting at Springfield, the two men could not help but clap
each other on the back as brothers-in-arms, and Pope took Grant to Governor
Yates and recommended Grant as his replacement. Benjamin Prentiss, the Militia
general, had been given command of Illinois forces, at Cairo, protecting the
southeastern sector of the state, and Pope, soon to be a brigadier-general of
volunteers, was to protect the northwestern sector by taking control of the
railroads in North Missouri. Happy to have another West Point graduate at his
call, Governor Yates quickly offered the job of Mustering Officer to Grant and
Grant accepted. Six weeks later, on July 17, 1861, with all the State's allocated regiments now mustered in and split between Pope and Prentiss, Yates
appointed Grant, colonel of the Twenty-First Illinois Volunteer Regiment, and
assigned him to Pope's command.
In the month that followed, Grant's regiment marched to Quincy, coming under the command for a time of Brigadier-General Hurlbut, and, then,
receiving orders from Pope, who had been placed by Fremont in command of North Missouri, he marched his regiment into Missouri, taking post at Palmyra, on the line
of the Hannibal & St. Joseph Railroad. By July 19th, Grant was under orders
to take his regiment on a steamer to St. Louis, for transit down the Iron
Mountain Railroad to Ironton, but the steamer failed to arrive and the order
was countermanded by McClellan. In the absence of Fremont, who was enroute to
St. Louis from New York, and Nathaniel Lyon who was about to join battle with
Price at Wilson's Creek, Lyon's adjutant, in command at St. Louis, had asked
Pope for troops to cover Ironton in the face of Confederate forces appearing in
force on the west bank of the Mississippi.
Countermanded Orders Would have Placed Him At Ironton
On July 25, Fremont reached St. Louis, and taking command of
the department, issued movement orders, to counter the Confederate threat that had
materialized in the southeast sector of the State when Polk and Pillow, with
10,000 men, appeared at New Madrid. (By this time, both Pope and Hurlburt were
brigadier-generals of volunteers; Prentiss, a militia brigadier at this time, was
about to become, along with Grant, a brigadier general of volunteersu0097all four
of these men were Illinoisans.) Once, again, John Pope stepped up as Grant's
sponsor, introducing Grant to Fremont when they met in St. Louis as "an
old Army officer of intelligence and discretion, thoroughly a gentleman and a
prudent man who is eminently needed now." (So much for the historians'
narrative of Grant's woebegone status among his acquaintances.)
The first thing Fremont appears to have done upon his
arrival in St. Louis was to take a steamer down the Mississippi and inspect the
situation of Prentiss's command at Cairo. Prentiss was struggling at this time
with the transition going on, reorganizing the men in the ninety day volunteer
regiments, whose enlistments were expiring, into three year regiments. On July
30, Fremont wired Lincoln: "Within a circle of 50 miles around Prentiss there
are about 12,000 rebel troops, and 5,000 Tennesseans, under Hardee, are
advancing on Ironton." On August 1, he reached Cairo with eight
transports, bringing reinforcements. Fremont remained at Cairo for five days,
in the course of which he had plenty of time to evaluate Prentiss as a soldier.
Returning to St. Louis, on August 6, Fremont sent orders to Pope to detach the
14th, 15th, and 21st Illinois Regiments from railroad guard duty in North Missouri, and send them to St. Louis.
As the regiments were marching, word came to Missouri that the Senate had approved Lincoln's appointment of both Prentiss and Grant as
brigadier-generals of volunteers with date of rank retroactive to May 17.
Clearly, Lincoln's appointment was caused by recommendations made by Illinois politicians, Governor Yates, Senator Trumbull, and Congressman Elihu Washburne,
whose congressional district included Galena.
Fremont, though neither a graduate of West Point nor a
veteran who had seen action in Mexicou0097he had been in California at the time, orchestrating
the brief-lived Bear Flag Republicu0097no doubt had enough sense to respect not
only Pope's opinion of Grant but also Grant's heavy record of battlefield experience
gained in the Mexican War, because, on August 8, he chose Grant to command at
the emerging hot spot of Ironton.
Acceptance of Commission as
was on August 25; before that date
Prentiss had a legitimate case he was senior.
Note: Congress passed its first act, approving
Lincoln's appointments, on July 18; it passed a second act, expanding the
number of appointments authorized, on July 27, and a third act dealing with
increasing major-generals and brigadier-generals in the Regular Army at about
the same time.
On August 8, Fremont, at St. Louis, gave Grant new orders:
u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0 August 8, 1861u0097Morning
u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0 Charged with the
Command of the Ironton Force:
"A special train will be sent to
take your regiment to Jefferson Barracks this morning. You will proceed with it
(using the Iron Mountain Railroad) to Pilot Knob, and take command of the regiments
stationed there under Colonels Brown, Hecker, and Bland. You will find an
officer of engineers engaged in laying out entrenchments which you will push
forward with all possible dispatch. It is intended to strengthen the frontier
as to make it defensible against any force likely to be brought against it, and
to this end additional men and stores will be immediately sent forward. You are
to guard your front and be prepared for the contingency of a sudden movement
with the force under your command. A locomotive has been placed at
Here is the great turning point in which Grant emerges from
the vast pack of regimental officers, coming suddenly into the command of the
crucial strategic spot in the western theater which will send his star soaring.
Before receiving these orders, Grant had arrived in St. Louis, on August 5,
send down by Pope to influence Fremont to let Pope's counterinsurgency policy
stick. (Grant, in his memoirs, does not mention his appearance in
St. Louis or his meeting with Fremont, nor does he give John Pope the credit
he obviously deserves for boosting him into position to gain the key slot in Fremont's department.)
Fremont Makes A Quick Double-Switch
On August 9, from Ironton, Grant makes his
first report as brigadier-general: "I am led to believe," he writes Fremont, "there is no force within thirty miles of us that entertain the least idea
of attacking this position. But many of the officers, here, seem to have so
little command over their men, and military duty seems to be done so loosely,
that I fear our resistance would be in inverse ratio of the number of troops to
resist with. In two more days, however, I expect to have a very different state
of affairs and to improve it continuously." (Initiative)
On August 10, Grant writesu0097"No
information has been received to lead to the supposition that this place is in
danger of attack. Hardee today is at Greenville, with 2,000 men and 6 field
pieces. Another 1,000 are thrown forward to Brunot. I suggest that two
regiments at St. Louis be sent here for drill and discipline." (This
is a subordinate after his commander's heart.)
in the Southeast District
On August 12, Fremont writes: "Send one
column to Frederickstown and one to Centreville, taking possession of both
places to guard your flanks. Send a column to Greenville and keep the
At this point, Lyon is killed at Wilson's Creek. The War
Department reacts to this by sending telegrams to the western governors calling
for troops and artillery to be sent to Missouri. Orders go out from Fremont to
send troops to Rolla on which Lyon's army, now under Franz Sigel, is falling
back; and Pope's forces are moving toward Jefferson Cityu0097Fremont's fear being
that Hardee, in combination with Price and McCullough, will move west to
threaten the central part of the State.
On August 14, Fremont reports to Lincoln that Grant has been attacked at Ironton, the Iron Mountain Railroad seized at Big River Bridge, between Ironton and St. Louis, and he issues his proclamation announcing
marital law. Since no such attack had occurred, it seems that Fremont was
manufacturing a basis for taking over the State's functioning government.
It is way past time that the historians stop playing games, with cause
On August 15, Fremont receives this telegram
from Lincoln: "Been answering your messages since day before yesterday. Do
you receive the answers? The War Department has notified all the governors you
designated to forward all available force, and so telegraphed you. Have you
received these messages? Answer Immediately. A. Lincoln"
(Clearly something for historians to juxtapose between Fremont's proclamation
and the proof of the necessity of it.)
This, in Fremont's mind, must have been the great moment of
crisis. The rebels are in the ascendant it seems: Lyon killed, Sigel
retreating, Hardee and Price advancing. Cairo threatened. He reacts with a
flurry of orders, to Pope, to Sigel, and, surprisingly, to Prentissu0097for reasons
not objectively clear from the record.
Note: Aroused by events
to reinforce Grant's position at Ironton, does Fremont think that the rules of
rank make Prentiss's claim to rank superior to Grant's? Or does he think Grant
has in some way failed to execute the existing orders? It seems clear, by
reference to subsequent events, that Fremont must have, for a moment, misunderstood
the rules of rank. (Or the rules of rank were ambiguous: In the Mexican war, it
seems to have been decided that Regular army rank outranked volunteer (militia)
rank, which makes sense.)
On August 8, a civilian railroad
manager, who have traveled with Grant to Ironton, wrote Fremont this: "I
arrived here with General Grant and troops at 3:00 p.m. today, find all quiet. Gen. Grant I am pleased with. He will do to lead.
u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0 Saint Louis, August 15, 1861
Brig-Gen. B. M. Prentiss:
Sir: Four regiments of your command have been ordered to
leave Cairo by steamboats and disembark at Cape Girardeau, where they will
await orders. You are directed to repair tomorrow morning by railroad to that
place, and with these troops, taking the cars of the Iron Mountain Railroad,
proceed to Ironton. You will assume command of the whole force stationed at that
place, and will at first secure communications from St. Louis to Ironton. After
the accomplishment of this you will proceed to Frederickstown and to
Centreville, take possession of those places, and secure those positions by a
force sufficiently strong. You will then open communication with Cape Girardeau. You will also make reconnaissances in the direction of Greenville."
Fremont, Major-General Commanding.
Grant had sent Fremont a telegram on August 15th: "I
note the arrival of two regiments of infantry. I have ordered the 21st Illinois forward on the Greenville road, and the 24th Illinois upon the Frederickstown
road, with instructions to form a junction at Brunot. I expect to follow
tomorrow." And he was actively carrying out these movements when Prentiss
arrived on August 17th, with Fremont's order in hand.
As Grant tells it in his memoirs, though Fremont's order did not relieve him from duty at Ironton, he refused to serve under
Prentiss: "I knew," Grant writes, "that by law I was his senior,
and at that time even the President did not have the authority to assign a
junior to command a senior of the same grade. I therefore started for St. Louis the same day." (Initiative) (Grant treated Prentiss shabbily
when the tables were turned.)
At St. Louis, he had contact with Fremont's staff and found
himself under orders to proceed to Jefferson City and take command at that
post. On August 10, Fremont had received a telegram from Pope, requesting that
Grant be ordered to report to him to relieve Gen. Hurlbut in the command
"in North and Northeast Missouri." The request made, because Pope
wanted Grant to "supervise the disaffected counties north of the Hannibal
& St. Joseph Railroad." Grant arrived at Jefferson City on August 21
and remained there eight days. (This is a perfectly reasonable explanation for
why Prentiss was now in command at Ironton. Fremont replaced Grant with him,
because Pope wanted Grant back! The historians have got to get
their act together: Grant, far from being an outcast, was perceived by both
Pope and Fremont as a dynamite asset..)
On August 25, Fremont sent orders to Prentiss,
now commanding in Grant's place at Ironton: "4,000 rebels are fortifying Benton, Mo. 1,500 more at Commerce. To disperse these forces a combined attack by your
troops and those at Cape Girardeau has been determined upon. You are ordered to
move forthwith to Dallas, then you will attack the rebels at Jackson, then,
with Smith, you will march upon the enemy at Benton."
Two days later, Fremont makes an abrupt about turn: On August
27, he ordered Grant to leave Jefferson City and come to St. Louis. The next day, on August 28, he ordered Grant to proceed to Cape Girardeau and assume command of the forces at that place with the view to making a
"combined attack with the troops at Ironton. Prentiss has therefore been
directed to proceed toward Cape Girardeau. The force, now in command at Cape Girardeau, has been instructed to move toward Prentiss and unite with him at or near Jackson. You upon assuming command at Cape Girardeau will act
accordingly." Then Fremont wrote a telegram to Prentiss explaining what
was happening. (Back in the saddle again!)
To Benjamin Prentiss, Fremont wrote:
u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0 St. Louis, August 28, 1861
Brig. Gen. B.M. Prentiss:
Sir: Brigadier-General Grant has been
directed to proceed to Cape Girardeau, assume command of the forces there, and
cooperate with the troops moving from Ironton. When you were ordered to go to
Ironton and take the place of Gen. Grant, it was under the impression that his
appointment was of a later date than your own. By the official list published
it appears, however, that he is your senior in rank. He will, therefore,
upon effecting a junction with your troops, take command of the whole
Fremont, Major-General Commanding
Thus, topsy-turvy like, Grant regained command of the Southeast
District of Missouri, including the garrison at Cairo, and held in his
hands, suddenly, the grand opportunity to be in position, to drive
the Union war effort deep into Tennessee and into Alabama. And Grant wasted no
time taking advantage of it.
Four days later, on September 2, Prentiss, having reached Cape Girardeau, refused to execute Grant's orders.
u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0 Cairo, Ill., September 2, 1861
Major-General Fremont, commanding Western Department:
I left Cape Girardeau at 10 o'clock this morning. General Prentiss raised the question of rank, and finally refused
to obey my orders. Last night he tendered his resignation and today he reported
himself in arrest. I will forward by tomorrow's mail the charges.
u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0 U.S. GRANT, Brigadier-General
Nothing came of Grant's charges; upon Prentiss reaching Fremont's headquarters, he was sent to Pope's district where he assumed Grant's old place,
guarding the Hannibal & St. Joseph Railroad from marauders and occupying
the county seats. Benjamin Prentiss was suddenly in the outlands, but he would
come under Grant's command, again, and he would save Grant's star from
crashing. (It is obvious that, having sent Grant to Pope, Fremont wanted him back at the hot spot of Ironton.)
Grant Seizes Paducah
When he assigned Grant to command the District of Southeast
Missouri, Fremont was thinking of the volatile situation in Kentucky,
anticipating the necessity of seizing Columbus, Kentucky, and thereby extending
the scope of his department to include western Kentucky and Tennessee. On
September 3, Fremont directed Grant to occupy Belmont, a hamlet on the west
bank of the Mississippi River, opposite Columbus, Kentucky, about 15 miles
below the confluence of the Mississippi and Ohio rivers. Columbus was the rail
head for the Mobile & Ohio Railroad.
On September 4, from Cairo, Grant wired Fremont that his
ability to keep a force at Belmont had been compromised by Prentiss's refusal
to accept his orders, and he had to withdraw his position at Jackson, Missouri. Grant told Fremont that it was "advisable to withdraw the troops from Belmont until the command assumes shape for concert of action." Grant sent a second
message that day to Fremont, advising that he believed the Confederate forces
on the Missouri side of the river were retiring to New Madrid and that he
thought it a good idea to take possession of Columbus as soon as the next day.
Then, abruptly, Grantu0097learning that Confederate forces had occupied Columbus in forceu0097wired a telegram to the Speaker of the Kentucky Legislature, at Frankfort informing him of that fact. (Initiative: Grant had no military
authority to do this thing!) The next day, September 5, Grant received a
message from Fremont which authorized him to take Paducah, if he felt strong
enough. (Later Fremont reprimanded him for communicating with the Kentucky
Whether or not Grant was already in motion before Fremont's message reached him, the record is not clear. What is clear is that, late in the
day, Grant went by steamer up the Ohio River and landed infantry at Paducah and occupied the place. Upon learning this, Fremont immediately assigned Brigadier-General
Charles F. Smith, who had recently arrived from the East, to command the
garrison at Paducah, reporting directly to Fremont, and he wrote Lincoln, asking that his department be extended to include the Tennessee River.
u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0 September 8, 1861
My Dear Sir: As the rebel troops driven
out from Missouri had invaded Kentucky in considerable force, and by occupying Union City, Hickman, and Columbus were preparing to seize Paducah and attack Cairo, I judged it impossible to defer any longer a forward movement. For this purpose I
have drawn from the Missouri side a force which I have placed at Fort Holt (a fort Grant was constructing on the south bank of the Ohio) and Paducah, of which places we have taken possession.
I have reinforced, yesterday, Paducah with two regiments and as soon as General Smith, who commands there, is reinforced
sufficiently, he will occupy Smithland, controlling in this way the mouths of
both the Tennessee and Cumberland Rivers. At the same time (a force should move
on Bowling Green from Louisville) and meanwhile General Grant would take
possession of New Madrid and the shore of the Mississippi opposite Columbus. A combined attack then will be made upon Columbus, and, if successful, we will
move in concert, by railroad, to Nashville, Tenn, occupying the state capital.
Then we would move on Memphis. (But Columbus was impregnable, it had to
By extending my command to Indiana, Tennessee, and Kentucky you would enable me to accomplish much.
truly yours, JOHN C. FREMONT
Two months later, after Fremont pushed forward a large force
to Springfield, inducing the Confederate generals, Price and McCulloch, to fall
back toward the Arkansas line, and Grant was keeping steady at Cairo and
Paducah, Lincoln, determining to let Fremont go, for a number of reasons, the
most pressing apparently being Fremont's gathering of political power, reached
out to Henry Halleck.
McClellan communicated the assignment to Halleck on November
9, writing that he should concentrate the "mass of the troops in the
department on or near the Mississippi, prepared for such ulterior operations
as the public interests may demand." At this time Fremont had the troops
organized as follows:
North Missouri (under Pope)u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0 5,400
At Jefferson Cityu00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0 9,600
At Rollau00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0 4,700
At Lexingtonu00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0 2,400
At Cairo (under Grant)u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0 15,500
At Paducah (under Smith)u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0 u00a0 7,000
Soon after Halleck assumed command of the department, the
concept of a campaign designed to drive the Confederates out of Kentucky began to develop in the War Department. Don Carlos Buell, assigned to command the
Department of the Ohio, was the first to formally submit in writing the idea
that a force be moved down the Louisville & Memphis Railroad to Bowling
Green in conjunction with two flotillas of gunboats steaming up the Tennessee
and Cumberland Rivers, so as to threaten Confederate forces at Bowling Green
and cut off communications between that place and Columbus.
The execution of this plan was delayed for three months by
several circumstances: first, its execution had to wait until sufficient
ironclad gunboats had been delivered to Cairo for use on the rivers; second,
Lincoln and McClellan pushed Buell for a number of months to divert his effort
on reaching Bowling Green in favor of pushing a column from Louisville to
Knoxville, a distance of 250 miles, the column to move without benefit of
either railroad or river; third, u00a0before Halleck could sufficiently reinforce
the expedition on the rivers, ensuring success in accomplishing its objective,
he had to clear Missouri of Confederate forces.
Halleck Wants To Dump Grant
Henry Halleck was a 4th year classman at West Point the year
Grant entered as a plebe. He was also an instructor of chemistry, French, and
engineering, and in that capacity had come into contact with Grant as a student,
though Grant claimed later not to remember this.
F. Smith, the brigadier-general commanding the forces at Paducah and Smithland,
independent of Grant's command at Cairo until Halleck arrived, had been the
Academy's Commandant of Cadets, during the period Halleck and Grant were at
West Point, serving in that position from 1838 to 1843. In addition to being at
West Point together, Grant and Smith had been together in Mexico, at the battles of Monterrey, with Taylor's army, and at Mexico City, with Scott's. (Smith
held the rank of colonel in the Regular army and was commissioned a
brigadier-general of volunteers on August 31, 1861.) Halleck had spend the
Mexican war years in California and after it ended, he remained in Northern
California, at Monterey and San Francisco, engaged in law practice and real
estate speculation until the Civil War broke out. As a consequence of this,
Halleck probably was aware of the rough circumstances in which Grant resigned
his army commission while stationed in Humboldt County.
It seems reasonable to conclude from these circumstances
that, when Halleck arrived in Missouri and found both Grant and Smith in
command, and he began thinking of how to drive the Confederates out of
Kentucky, that he naturally preferred Smith to Grant as the commander of the
expeditionary forces; this preference, u00a0by word and action, it appears Halleck
conveyed to Grantu0097for ten days after Halleck arrived, though he had added
Paducah to Grant's district, and thus allowed Smith to come under Grant's
command, Grant wrote this line in a letter to his father: "I am
somewhat troubled lest I lose my command here."
By January, with Smith's reconnaissance up the Tennessee, to within sight of Fort Henry, followed by the arrival at Cairo of Eads's
gunboats, under the command of Flag Officer Foote, Grant was pushing Halleck to
allow him to attack Fort Henry. He pestered Halleck with messages about the
viability of doing this, and he begged Halleck for an audience to explain his
plan. Grant tells what happenedu0097we are to presumeu0097in his memoirs:
"The interview was granted, but not graciously. I had not known General
Halleck in the old army, not having met him either at West Point or during the
Mexican War. I was received with so little cordiality. . . after uttering but a
few sentences I was cut short as if my plan was preposterous. I returned to Cairo very much chestfallen." (Grant makes it seem incredulous that Halleck would act
so.) Though "chestfallen," Grant wasted no time slamming Halleck
again. On January 28th, just a few days after returning from the contentious
meeting, he wired Halleck "I can take and hold Fort Henry, if
permitted." Supporting him, Foote fired off to Halleck an identical wire.
Halleck was clearly focused on organizing an expedition
against Fort Henry and Donelson, if he could find the troops and the money. On
January 20, just about the time he dished Grant, Halleck wrote to McClellan:
"I venture to make a few
suggestions in regard to the operations in the West. The most feasible plan is to
move up the Cumberland and Tennessee, making Nashville the first objective
point. This would turn Columbus and force the abandonment of Bowling Green. The
line of the Cumberland or Tennessee is the great central line of the Western
theater of war."
Soon, Halleck was shifting regiments from other places and
building Grant's force up; not because Grant had convinced him of his plan, but
because he had come to the independent conclusion that the movement could be
successful, that the time to launch it had arrived, and that, if he acted fast,
he would be able to take full credit for the success and, perhaps, end up broadening
the territorial limits of his department to include Tennessee. In Halleck'su00a0
mind it seems, Grant was at this time but a pawn while he was the chess master.
DEPARTMENT OF THE OHIO
u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0 Louisville, Ky, January 30, 1862
Maj. Gen George B. McClellan,
Commanding U.S. Army:
My Dear Friend: General Smith
reconnoitered Fort Henry. He says two or three gun boats could go right up
there and shell the place out. I believe his suggestion is feasible at this
time and I don't hesitate to urge the attempt. The destruction of the bridges
and the boats on the Cumberland and Tennessee Rivers is an object of great
importance. I have written to General Halleck on this subject and do not
hesitate to recommend it for your prompt consideration.
Truly, D.C. BUELL
Immediately Halleck shot back!
DEPARTMENT OF MISSOURI
u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0 Saint Louis, January 30, 1862
Brig. Gen. D.C. Buell, Louisville, Ky.
I have ordered an advance of our troops
on Fort Henry and Donelson. It will be made immediately.
Receiving this, Buell responded,
thinking Halleck meant to cooperate with his own advance across the Barren River, driving Johnston toward Nashville: "Please let me know your plan and
force and the time etc. Buell"
Halleck replied on January 31:
"Movement already ordered. Force about 15,000; and will be reinforced as
soon as possible."
To this Buell came back with, "Do
you consider active cooperation essential for your success?"
Halleck replied: "cooperation not
It seems obvious what had happened here. Halleck, as shown by
his previous communications available to you in the Rebellion Record, had intended
to eventually move up the Tennessee River and attack Fort Henry, but only after
he had cleared Missouri of Price and McCulloughu0097an operation then actively
underwayu0097and then draw enough forces from Missouri to increase
Grant's and Smith's forces from 15,000 to 30,000 men, if not more. (This is the
amount of men that concentrated finally at Donelson.) But the pace of events
made Halleck move quicker with less men: for, once Grant and Foote began
pressing him, with Smith's reconnaissance backing them up, and with Buell now
raising the issue with McClellan, the general commanding the Army, Halleck
realized he had to act fast if he was to get the credit.
And Grant, thus, the next day was on his way. Halleck's
strategic thinking, here, was that after Henry fell, he meant to move Grant
west toward the line of the Mobile & Ohio Railroad, cutting it, and thus
forcing Polk to abandon Columbus; then Halleck would move toward New Madrid
and, finally, toward Memphis, leaving Nashville to Buell. Nashville as a strategic
point meant nothing to him. He wrote Buell as much. But no sooner had Grant
captured Fort Donelson but he was directing not only his own troops but Buell's
as well, toward Nashville and this infuriated Halleck to the point he decided
to dump Grant and put Smith in his place
Note: How important to
the careers of Halleck and Buell that there be success in capturing Donelson is
seen in this letter Lincoln wrote to Halleck as Grant's force was being
attacked by Pillow's.
u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0 EXECUTIVE MANSION
u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0 Washington D.C., February 16, 1862
You have Donelson safe unless Grant
shall be overwhelmed from outside; to prevent which I think requires all your
skill and Buell's, acting in full cooperation. Columbus will not get at Grant,
but Johnson's force at Bowling Green will. (This is Lincoln's "military
advisors" talking.) They hold the railroad from Bowling Green to within a
few miles of Donelson. It is safe to rely that they will not dare expose Nashville to Buell. A small part of their force can retire slowly toward Nashville, breaking up the railroad as they go, and keep Buell out of
that city twenty days. Meanwhile Nashville will be defended by forces from all
the South. Our success or failure at Donelson is vastly important, and I beg you
to put your soul in the effort.
u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0 A. LINCOLN
Lincoln's sentences obscure what he is saying, but the
overall effect is to drive home to Halleck that he must cooperate
with Buell. The middle part of the message is simply filler to give space for Lincoln to make his point. It seems Lincoln was incapable of simply stating directly what
he meant; i.e., "Cooperate with Buell!" The business
about what Johnston might do ignores completely the realities of the matter.
True, Johnston held the railroad from Bowling Green to
within a few miles of Donelson, at the Clarksville Bridge. But Lincoln's statement that "they will not dare expose Nashville" to
Buell is silly. As is the idea that "a small part of their force can
retire slowly toward Nashville and keep Buell out of Nashville twenty
days." The whole tactical problem is that Johnston cannot "retire slowly" from Bowling Green. To do so, implies he has a great
force, great enough to detach a force large enough to overwhelm Grant from "outside"
as Lincoln states, and, at the same time, hold back Buell for twenty days. It
is apparent that Lincoln and his advisors did not know how weak Johnston was. (Here, in the records of both sides' communications, we see, at the outset, that
the Confederacy's weaknesses, in manpower and materiel, are so greatu0097relative
to the strengths of the Unionu0097that it cannot possibly expect to win the war
The only force Johnston has that can be used
for this purposeu0097holding Grant back, long enough to "slowly"
retire in front of Buell and "hold Nashville for twenty days"u0097is the
force under the command of Buckner, Floyd, and Pillow, who have taken post at
Clarksville, precisely for that purpose.
All Johnston cared about, it appears, was getting his main
body away from Bowling Green and Nashville, before Buell could force him into a general battle. It is plain from the undisputed
evidence that Johnston left it to the discretion of Floyd and Pillow where they would fight to keep Grant off the line of retreat the main body was rapidly taking toward Nashville. If he is to be criticized by
the historians and civil war writers, it must be, because he did not order Floyd and Pillow where to make the necessary stand. But his failure, if that is
what it can be called, to order Floyd and Pillow to meet Grant's advance at
Clarksville, instead of Donelson, may well have been reasonable: either way it
may well be that the defending troops would be lost in the process, unable to
disengage and get away wherever the battle was fought.
Apparently, Lincoln's advisors had no idea that the
so-called "Kentucky Line" was being defended by two separate forces
under separate commandersu0097Johnston and Polku0097with Polk making decisions without
regard to Johnston's situation; which meant that there was no way Sidney
Johnston could "get at Grant" and keep Buell north of Bowling Green at
the same time. Given the weakness of his force at Bowling Green, Johnston knew early on that he could not stand there against Buell, but would have to retreat
as soon as Buell could cross the Barren River; and his retreat could not stop
at Nashville because the place could not be defended for the same reason.
The amazing thing is that, under such circumstances, Johnston allowed Pillow to talk him into reinforcing Donelson instead of evacuating it
before Grant invested it. Johnston could not reasonably have expected the
Confederate force, once in place at Donelson, to be able to successfully
retreat to Nashville, or if he did think this the basis for it cannot be objectively
discerned from the record.
A rational explanation for Johnston's decision to allow
Pillow to reinforce Donelson, as stated above, is the fact that he thought he was
unable to draw his forces away from Bowling Green and get to Nashville, before
Grant, easily overcoming the obstacle of Donelson, could get across his
line of retreat. Pillow did hold Donelson for two days, just the amount of time
Johnston needed to reach Nashville. Pillow and Floyd could have waited at
Clarksville to meet the Union advance from the direction of Donelson, but they
still would have apparently been forced to fight a battle, if Johnston's main
body was to safely reach Nashville far enough ahead of Buell to get away. So
Pillow chose to fight the battle at Donelson instead of Clarksville.
Halleck Tries To Dump Grant
No sooner had Grant captured Donelson than Halleck began
making efforts to supercede him in command of the field forces on the Cumberland, writing Buellu0097"I have asked the President to make you a major-general.
Come down to the Cumberland and take command. The battle of the West is to be
fought in that vicinity. You should be in it as the ranking general in
immediate command. Don't hesitate. Come to Clarksville as rapidly as possible.
Say that you will come and I will have everything there for you."
The reason for Halleck's reaching out to Buell is clear
here. Though Grant had indeed captured Donelson his absence from the field at
the time the Confederates attacked his forces almost lost it. As Halleck said,
in his message to Buell: "We came within an ace of being defeated. If the
reinforcements which I sent down had not reached there on Saturday we should
have gone in. (This is not an exaggeration.) A retreat at one time seemed
almost inevitable." Buell's date of rank as brigadier-general gave him
seniority over Grant.
At the same time as this, taking another tack, Halleck asked
McClellan to make Ethan Hitchcock, Lincoln's advisor, a major-general and sent
him to the west; Halleck planning here to use Hitchcock to manage affairs at
his headquarters while he, himself, took command of Grant's army in the field.
Taking yet another tack toward the same result, Halleck reminded McClellan that
"it was decided in the Mexican War that regulars outranked volunteers
without regard to dates." If this decision were sustained now, Halleck
said, it would make everything "right for the Western Division." (Smith,
holding Regular army rank as colonel, would be recognized, under the rule, as senior
to Grant whose army rank was captain.) On the heels of these messages, Halleck
wrote another to McClellan which makes his mind-set crystal clear: Halleck
wanted Grant superceded any way he could manage it.
Saint Louis, February 19, 1862
Brig.Gen Charles F. Smith, by his
coolness and bravery at Fort Donelson when the battle was against us,
(not quite) turned the tide and carried the enemy's breastworks. Make him a
major-general. You can't get a better one. Honor him for this victory and the
whole country will applaud.
Instead, Lincoln made Grant a major-general, with "date
of rank" being the date Donelson fell. Hitchcock stayed in Washington and
Smith, made a major-general on March 21, remained Grant's junior in rank.
Notwithstanding this, Halleck continued to build a basis to move Grant out of
On March 3, he wrote McClellan: "I have had no
communication from Grant for more than a week. His army seems to be as much
demoralized by the victory of Fort Donelson as was that of the Potomac by the defeat of Bull Run. Satisfied with his victory, he sits down and enjoys it
without any regard to the future. C.F. Smith is almost the only officer equal
to the emergency." McClellan wired back almost instantlyu0097Do not hesitate
to arrest him at once and place C.F. Smith in command." How tenuous sits
Then came this to McClellan from Halleck.
DEPARTMENT OF THE MISSOURI
u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0u00a0 Saint Louis, March 4, 1862
Major-General McClellan, Washington
A rumor has just reached me that since
taking Fort Donelson General Grant has resumed his former bad habits. If so, it
will account for his neglect of my often-repeated orders. I have placed General
Smith in command of the expedition up the Tennessee (to Pittsburg Landing and
beyond). I think Smith will restore order and discipline."
And to Grant, on March 4, Halleck wrote this terse
Maj.Gen. U.S. Grant, Fort Henry
You will place Maj. Gen C. F. Smith in
command of expedition, and remain yourself at Fort Henry.
Note: Smith was not in fact a
major-general as of March 4. His date of rank was March 21, 1862.
Grant, in his Memoirs, explains the circumstances underpinning Halleck's March 4th order this way: "On the 2nd of March I received orders dated March 1 to move my command back to Fort Henry. From Fort Henry expeditions were to be sent against Eastport and Paris. On the 6th Halleck wrote me again, `Your going to Nashville without authority" was his reason for [having Smith supercede me in command of the expedition up the Tennessee]. That place was not beyond the limits of my command because it had been expressly declared in orders that the limits of my command were `not defined.' On the 13th of March I was restored to command. On receipt of the order I proceeded to Savannah. General Smith was delighted to see me. He was on a sick bed at the time, from which he never came away alive." (edited for brevity)
The historians and civil war writers have heaped much ridicule upon Henry Halleck for his handling of Grant at this time; however, Halleck had—the objective record reflects—legitimate reasons for limiting Grant's authority for a short time to the environs of Fort Henry. On March 2, Halleck had ordered Grant to move his forces from Donelson to Henry, not aware at the time that Grant had gone to Nashville where Smith's division had gone, apparently under orders from Carlos Buell. McClellan, as general-in-chief, appears to have been pestering Halleck for a statement of the number of troops and their depositions, under Grant's command, and Halleck, in turn, was irritated at Grant for not having timely provided them.
At or near the same time, Halleck had received a letter from Illinois Judge David Davis, a close friend of Lincoln, complaining of the fact that government supplies, delivered to Donelson, had been redirected into private hands and had made their way into Illinois to be sold on the civilian market. Compounding his displeasure with Grant was the fact that Grant's troops, in the days following the victory at Donelson, had pillaged the surrounding countryside, without, apparently, Grant taking any action to stop them. On top of this, an officer had made accusations that Grant was seen repeatedly in circumstances that suggested he was dead drunk. So it ought not come as a surprise that Halleck decided to put Smith in Grant's place to command the "advance" of the expedition up the Tennessee River.
HEADQUARTERS DEPARTMENT OF THE MISSOURI
Saint Louis, March 6, 1862
Maj. Gen. U.S. Grant, Fort Henry
I inclose a copy of a letter addressed to Judge Davis. Judge Davis says the writer is a man of integrity and perfectly reliable.
The want of order and discipline and the numerous irregularities in your command since the capture of Donelson are matters of general notoriety, and have attracted the serious attention of the authorities at Washington. Unless things are immediately corrected, I am directed to relieve you of the command.
H.W. HALLECK, major-general
But the evidence preponderates in favor of the conclusion that, after making a brief effort to get Washington's approval for dumping Grant, Halleck decided he had no choice, however unpalatable to his taste Grant was, but to leave Grant in command of the District of West Tennessee, which command Grant continued to hold at the time he returned to Fort Henry on March 5; especially if Grant got his act together which he promptly did.
Halleck, at this time, was doing everything in his power to move as much force as possible from every point in his department to the rear staging area of Paducah and up the Tennessee, to reinforce the advance now being made under Smith's command; the object of which was to reach as far as Eastport—with its strategic objective to establish an advanced staging area for an attack on Corinth, Mississippi, the railroad crossroads between the Mobile & Ohio Railroad and the Memphis & Charleston Railroad. Everything Halleck did, between March 4 and March 17th, when Grant took command at Savannah, was geared to accomplish this goal.
On March 5th, Halleck wired Grant, who then was at Fort Henry, the following: "It is exceedingly important that there should be no delay in destroying the bridge at Corinth or Bear Creek. If successful, the expedition will not return to Paris, but will encamp at Savannah, unless threatened by superior numbers. Prepare everything to reinforce Smith there." At this time, Halleck had Sherman in command at Paducah, forwarding troops to Grant at Henry, for movement forward to Smith, as he could free them from reserve duty in Missouri, where they were backing up Curtis in his pursuit of Van Dorn into Arkansas and Pope's efforts to capture the Confederates blocking the Mississippi at Island No. Ten. Plainly, Halleck needed Grant at Henry, managing the movement of gunboats and transports on the Tennessee, more than he needed Grant leading the "advance" of an expedition which, in its initial stages, would be establishing an advanced staging area in anticipation of an advance overland to Corinth where Halleck expected "the battle of the West" to take place.
While Halleck was engaged in the effort to shift the weight of his force from Missouri to Tennessee, he was dealing with McClellan in Washington (and indirectly with Stanton and Lincoln) trying to gain power over Buell. Buell, during this time, made repeated requests upon Halleck, to meet with him in Louisville and plan the campaign against the rebel's new center, together; but Halleck dodged the requests. On March 6, Buell wired his friend, McClellan, "it is important that Halleck and I should meet. I have proposed Louisville. Can you meet us there? When McClellan pressed Halleck to meet with Buell, he responded, on March 7, with "I cannot leave here to meet Buell till Fort Henry, New Madrid, and Ironton are connected by telegraph. Curtis is calling for reinforcements. I must be in reach to aid him by telegram."
Buell wanted the meeting in order that an understanding could be reached as to who was do what and who was to command. That Halleck wanted command of Buell's troops is evident from his communications during these early days of March. On the 7th he wired Buell: "If you determine to send any troops to Tennessee, please let me know when and how many." On the 8th went this to Buell: "Do you intend to send any troops to the Tennessee, and, if so, how many and when? My own movements are delayed for this information." On the 9th Buell answered: "I suggest the following: Savannah is the only point from which we can operate centrally. If you occupy that point I will reinforce you by water or join you by land; if we could meet I think we could better understand each other." (edited for clarity)
On the 10th Halleck wired McClellan this: "I am surprised that Buell should hesitate to reinforce me. He was too late at Donelson. I am obliged to make my calculations independent of him. Believe me, general, you make a serious mistake in having two independent commands in the West. There never will and never can be any cooperation at the critical moment." And then he ended bluntly: "You will regret your decision against me on this point. Your friendship for individuals has influenced your judgment. Be it so. I shall soon fight a great battle on the Tennessee unsupported, as it seems, but if successful it will settle the campaign in the West."
These are bold, and for McClellan, must have been exasperating words, as, at this very moment, McClellan, already in the process of moving the Army of the Potomac down Chesapeake Bay bound for Fort Monroe—Joe Johnston's army having abruptly abandoned Manassas on the 9th—was about to drop out of his status as "general-in-chief" and Buell was about to lose the benefit of being his friend.
Halleck also, on the 10th, wired Lorenzo Thomas, Adjutant General, that Grant had given explanations which satisfied him and, thus had been "directed to resume his command in the field. There never was any want of military subordination on the part of General Grant. All irregularities have now been remedied," Halleck now said.
As these communications were going back and forth between Halleck, Buell, and McClellan, Lincoln, despite the distraction of his youngest son dying, the appearance of the Confederate ironclad Merrimac in Hampton Roads, and the political complexities of dealing with McClellan, must have had his fingers feeling the pulse.
Thomas Scott, an assistant to Secretary of War Stanton, was on the scene in Halleck's theater, traveling from St. Louis, to Cairo, to Paducah, and to Nashville: interviewing general officers, watching the troop movements, and reporting to his superior, Stanton. On March 6th, Scott wired Halleck, "If you want Buell to send you 10,000 or 20,000 by river or land, he will undoubtedly send them." The same day, Scott wired Stanton: "The enemy has 20,000 men at Corinth, Miss; 10,000 at Henderson, 25 miles from Corinth; and 8,000 at Bear River Bridge, near Alabama line; and are daily receiving reinforcements from Columbus, from Louisiana, and from other points. They will probably make decided stand there, and require a large army well managed to beat them. Will General McClellan meet Western generals for consultation? Halleck is now moving up Tennessee, but I think his own force is inadequate for work before them." This message surely carried home to Lincoln the knowledge that the "large army" required would have to include Buell's.
Halleck had wired this to Scott on March 7th, which day seems decisive in the foretelling of the event that was to follow.
HEADQUARTERS DEPARTMENT OF MISSOURI
Saint Louis, March 7, 1862
Thomas Scott, Asst. Sec. War Cairo
I telegraphed Buell to reinforce me strongly at or near Savannah. The enemy's line of defense is now an oblique one, extending from Island No. Ten to Decatur and Chattanooga. We must again pierce his center at Savannah or Florence. Buell should move immediately, and not come in too late as he did at Donelson.
H.W. HALLECK, Major-General
Stanton replied to Scott's message on March 8: "Your telegram received with great satisfaction. Buell will be nominated a major general tomorrow. Andrew Johnson will be appointed Military Governor of Tennessee. You will remain at Nashville with Buell, advising me daily of the state of operations. The President is much pleased with the cautious vigor (Huh?) of General Buell, and relies upon that to guard, above all things, against any mishap by premature and unsupported movements, and expects cordial concert of action between him and General Halleck." Reading this, today, in light of the actual facts, it is difficult to fathom what Stanton (and presumably Lincoln) was thinking. Put in direct language, Stanton is saying Lincoln is counting on Buell to temper Halleck's aggressiveness in pushing forces toward Savannah for a confrontation with Sidney Johnston, which Buell can achieve by moving slowly?
Within a matter of just a few days, though, Lincoln suddenly radically changes the command set up. Why he does this, in relation to Halleck and Buell, the record provides no intelligent explanation, given Stanton's message to Scott three days before.
On March 11, came the President's War Order No. 3.
Before the issuance of this order the chain of command was this:
David Hunter Henry Halleck Don Carlos Buell
After the order's issuance, the chain of command was this:
Lincoln- - - "War Board" (Hitchcock)
Henry Halleck John Fremont George McClellan
The War Order specified that Hunter's department (Kansas) be consolidated with Halleck's department (Missouri) and that "so much of Buell's department as lies west of a north/south line passing through Knoxville be incorporated into Halleck's department, the name of which is changed to "Department of the Mississippi." The territory between the north/south line and the western boundary of the Department of the Potomac (under McClellan's command) is now called the Mountain Department to be commanded by John C. Fremont. It is easy to understand Lincoln's reasons for reducing McClellan's command function to that of a field commander of an army and his reasons for taking troops away from the Army of the Potomac and giving them to Fremont for use in the "Mountain Department," but it is difficult, if not impossible, to understand (unless Stanton was clueless as to Lincoln's state of mind) what prompted Lincoln to reduce Buell to Halleck's subordinate. Of course, suddenly Halleck had in his own hands the "large army" he needed to guarantee battle success over Sidney Johnston's. (Though now a major-general at this time, Buell is outranked by Grant)
One can, like the historians do generally, speculate as to Lincoln's thinking: Perhaps, dumping McClellan, Lincoln thought it necessary to dump McClellan's friend and, indeed, Halleck did have his hands firmly on the reins, moving the bulk of his resources (not enough according to Scott) forward toward a decisive battle or control of the Tennessee Valley.
Days before Lincoln's war order number three came down, Halleck had already set Grant back on course to take command of the forward operating base that Smith had established at Savannah, though it is clear from the record that Halleck intended to go quickly to Savannah and take supreme command of the operations. He wanted to be there in command when the battle came down. (One must assume from the evidence that Grant understood this, and took certain actions, or not, in order that the battle might happen before Halleck arrived to grab the credit.)
On March 9, two days before Lincoln's war order was issued, Grant wired Halleck the information he demanded, regarding troops dispositions—by that date Grant had 25,000 infantry at Savannah, with 3000 cavalry and 12 artillery batteries—and Halleck immediately replied with this: "You will hold yourself in readiness to take the command. There will probably be some desperate fighting in that vicinity, and we must be prepared. See that intrenching tools are forwarded." And he followed it with this message on the 10th: "Transports with troops going up; arrange for them as they arrive, and ready yourself to take the general command." Then, on the 13th, after Grant continued to complain of Halleck's prior treatment, Halleck wired: "Instead of relieving you, I wish you as soon as your new army is in the field to assume the immediate command and lead it on to new victories."
On March 14th, with Smith at Savannah, having already suffered an injury that would prove fatal, Sherman arrived at Pittsburg Landing, with a division of raw troops, and moved a brigade eight miles through the woods on a reconnaissance in the direction of Corinth.
Three days later Grant arrived at Savannah and send forward this message to Sherman at Pittsburg Landing, "I have ordered all troops here to report to you immediately. Organize them into brigades and attach them to divisions as you think best." The same day, Buell wired Halleck: "I have information that Beauregard moved from Corinth probably toward Savannah, to operate against Smith." Halleck replied: "I fully understand these movements. Move on, as ordered today, to reinforce Smith. Savannah is now the strategic point. Don't fail to carry out my instructions. I know I am right."
On March 17, as Grant arrived at Savannah and resumed
command, his army now was organized into six divisions, commanded respectively
by Lew Wallace, W.H. L. Wallace, McClernand, who had come from his post at
Cairo, Hurlbut, who had come from North Missouri, and William Sherman, who
Halleck had given a new division composed of raw recruits. Reinforcements were
arriving at Savannah daily and, as they accumulated into brigades, Grant
assigned them as a division to Benjamin Prentiss who Halleck had also sent from
Over the next two weeks, these divisions were moved, on
transport steamers, from Savannah to Pittsburg Landing and placed in camps
about two miles from the river bank, with Prentiss's and Sherman's divisions
being farthest in front, about three miles from the river.
Situation Would Bring Grant's Army Within a Hair of Destruction
What Happened in March 1862
The War In The East March 1862